Revista ELectrónica de Investigación y EValuación Educativa

Español

RELIEVE

 English

Electronic Journal of Educational Research and Evaluation

Form for the review of pre-prints

Article: 
Reviewer: 

Is the subject of this paper relevant to the Journal? Yes
 No
Does the paper contain new data or new ideas? / Is the new and original contribution? (For review articles this need not necessarily apply) Yes
 No
Are interpretations and conclusions sound, justified by the data and consistent with the objectives? Yes
 No

If the answers to any of above three points are negative, please give clear arguments here.
If the answers to the above three points are positive, then please continue with the following.

Does the title clearly reflect its contents? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Is the abstract sufficiently informative, especially when read in isolation? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
If applicable, are adequate Keywords given? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Is this paper clearly written for a diverse audience of Scientists? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Are the references adequate and in agreement with the Guide for Authors? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No

Only for empirical paper
Is the organisation of article satisfactory (e.g. no discussion in Results)? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Is the description of materials and methods adequate? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Are the results clearly presented? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No
Are the discussion and conclusions consistent with the results? Absolutely
 Very well
 Well
 A few
 No

Recomendation to the Editor (choose an option)
The manuscript is acceptable as it is (or with a few corrections)
The manuscript may become acceptable after major revision
The manuscript is not acceptable

Other additional comments:

     


THANK YOU FOR YOUR COLLABORATION

  [Principal]  [Artículos publicados]  [Guía para autores]  [Contacta con nosotros] 

 [Home Page] [ Published Articles]  [Guide for authors]  [Contact with us]

Revista ELectrónica de Investigación y EValuación Educativa http://www.uv.es/RELIEVE

email: relieve@uv.es