Digitalisation and recent crises have accelerated profound transformations in the use of urban and rural space, affecting commerce, tourism, and the provision of basic services.
Key Findings
3.1. Rise of the polycentric urban model and the new work geography.
Studies on Madrid and Zaragoza (2.7) show that we are not facing the ‘death of the centre’. A polycentric urban model is taking shape: city centres are maintaining their role as hubs for interaction and ‘reactive’ services (commerce, finance, leisure), while the periphery is gaining new prominence as a logistics hub (driven by the ‘delivery economy’ and the growth of courier services) and as a place of residence and teleworking for knowledge-based services. Studies of Madrid show us the multi-scalar nature of urban logistics networks, observing growth throughout the metropolitan periphery in warehouses and logistics facilities, but also within the central city, associated with the so-called ‘last mile’.
3.2. Paradox of commercial revitalisation: homogeneisation, deserts and cannibalism.
The pandemic has accelerated commercial reconfiguration processes in urban spaces, driven by changes in consumption patterns and the digitisation of the sector. Large retail chains have led a ‘return to the centre’ with flagship store models, located in iconic areas and tourist hotspots (7). While this revitalises certain areas, it also leads to a homogenisation of the landscape, as well as the creation of ‘commercial deserts’ in declining areas and working-class neighbourhoods (18). Local actors confirm this trend, estimating a 10% loss in the commercial fabric since 2019, mainly local and neighbourhood commerce, while noting the proliferation of empty premises (6) in neighbourhoods and new developments, as well as ‘cannibalisation’ between shopping centres, or forcing others to transform radically.
3.3. Urban dynamics: types of streets and service commerce transformation.
In medium-sized cities in Catalonia, categorising urban streets into Attraction, Stay, Walkability and Residual is essential to understanding the evolution of retail trade and the vitality of urban centres. Each type of street fulfils a specific function, directly influenced by socio-economic dynamics and the constant transformation of the commercial landscape. Attraction Streets in urban centres are changing: essential shops are moving to the outskirts and there is an increase in restaurants and services, indicating a clear shift towards tourism, leisure and experiential consumption. Stay Streets complement this trend, offering rest areas that enhance the visitor experience. Walkability Streets act as vital infrastructure, efficiently connecting all these areas and facilitating pedestrian movement. In contrast, Residual Streets remain on the margins, with little activity and no contribution to this new central vitality. Thus, the evolution of commerce not only changes the type of establishments, but also redefines the purpose and interaction between different types of streets, creating a more specialised and experiential urban centre.
3.4. Two sides of proximity:comerce sector validation.
Retailers confirm the ‘revaluation of proximity’, with 46% of Valencian consumers shopping close to home. However, they also validate the paradox: the loss of 10% of the local commercial fabric since 2019 and the proliferation of empty premises, while large chains are reorganising and business models based on the circular economy and fast food convenience are growing exponentially (6). In the case of Zaragoza, local and neighbourhood retailers view the reconfiguration of the sector with concern, although they highlight proximity as one of their main values and attractions, particularly in working-class neighbourhoods. For their part, public policies to support local and neighbourhood commerce have been very insufficient during the post-pandemic period, focusing on loyalty programmes and direct incentives for consumption and on aid for the digitisation of the sector, with little focus on the real needs of small businesses. Other aid has focused on intervening in public spaces to improve their quality and boost commerce, in some cases creating ‘open shopping centres’ (18, 19).
3.5. The hybrid commerce paradox: a urban consumer dilemma.
In medium-sized cities in Catalonia, consumers face a dilemma. On the one hand, they are attracted by the convenience of shopping online or in large stores. On the other hand, they want to support local businesses. This situation creates a paradox in their purchasing decisions. This tension manifests itself in various ways among users of urban centres: from the ‘conscious consumer’, who experiences a conflict between their values and practicality, to the ‘urban experience consumer’, who prioritises leisure and culture, or the ‘functional consumer’, who seeks efficiency, and the ‘stroller’, whose purchases are more spontaneous. Each profile navigates and resolves, in their own way, this complex scenario of options in the heart of the city.
3.6. Cycledistribbution and the consumer paradox: sustainaility vs convenience in the 'last mile'.
Urban goods distribution is changing, and cycledistribution is emerging as a key sustainable alternative for last-mile logistics. Consumers prioritise speed, price and convenience without being influenced by socio-demographic factors in terms of environmental and social awareness.
3.7. Child mobility in Barcelona: past Eixample.
The results of our study reveal that the apparent functionality of neighbourhoods such as Barcelona's Eixample district does not always translate into good autonomous mobility for children. In these neighbourhoods, heavy traffic and a lack of green spaces generate feelings of fear and limit child development. Interestingly, the neighbourhoods with the highest scores on the Child Autonomous Mobility Index (MAI) are the old historic centres of annexed towns such as Sants, Gràcia, Les Corts and Sant Andreu. In contrast, the neighbourhoods with the lowest MAI scores are the outlying ones, which are characterised by their vulnerability, insecurity, dispersion and lack of adequate spaces and uses for children.
3.8. Financial exclusion: the dark side of digitalisation in countryside territory.
The same optimisation strategies that are a sign of resilience in urban areas (online banking) cause exclusion in rural areas. The study on Aragon (9) identifies ‘Type I financial exclusion’ (total absence of branches in small, ageing municipalities) and ‘Type II’ (saturation of the few remaining offices in larger towns and cities). This process, driven by post-2008 banking restructuring and the effects of the pandemic, exacerbates the vicious cycle of depopulation and ageing.
3.9. From tourism onoculture to intelligent diversification.
The analysis of tourist destinations (8) reveals two contrasting models. On the one hand, there is the vulnerability of ‘insularity’ and tourism monoculture (Balearic Islands), which generates overtourism and pressure on resources. On the other hand, there is the model of medium-sized cities such as Osuna, which are committed to intelligent diversification, capitalising on intangible assets to create innovative products such as ‘film tourism’ (the ‘Game of Thrones’ effect). This is complemented by the rise of ‘creative tourism’, based on the co-creation of experiences with local talent.